What happened
Researchers led by the University of Southern California, with authors from Genentech, Roche and other US centres, re-analysed the OPERA I and II trials, which compared ocrelizumab with interferon beta-1a for two years in relapsing multiple sclerosis (MS). In the interferon group, non-Hispanic Black and Hispanic or Latino participants had a higher risk of disability worsening confirmed after 24 weeks, measured with a combined (composite) disability measure, than non-Hispanic White participants (hazard ratio 3.0 and 2.3). Non-Hispanic Black and Hispanic or Latino participants also had more CD19-positive B cells at the start. In 1,138 participants who consented to genetic analysis, higher African or Americas genetic ancestry was also linked to higher risk. Ocrelizumab lowered B cells in all groups. Compared with interferon, it lowered the risk of this composite disability worsening in Hispanic or Latino participants (hazard ratio 0.38; 95% confidence interval 0.20–0.72). In the 65 Black participants the estimate also pointed to lower risk (hazard ratio 0.41), but the 95% confidence interval of 0.13–1.29 includes no difference, so the result is not statistically significant.
What this means for people with MS
This is not a new treatment or a new approval: ocrelizumab is already an approved MS treatment. The analysis was done after the trials ended, in small subgroups (only 65 Black participants), using self-reported race and ethnicity; it cannot show why risk differed and does not change treatment guidance. The authors conclude that ocrelizumab reduced risk regardless of race or ethnicity, but for Black participants the study alone does not establish this. It does not establish availability or reimbursement in Greece or support changing an individual treatment without a neurologist.
About the approach studied in this programme: OPERA I and II (ocrelizumab)
Ocrelizumab is an antibody that binds CD20 on B cells and reduces that immune-cell population. OPERA I and II compared this approach with interferon beta-1a for relapsing MS during the randomized period, then followed participants receiving ocrelizumab in an open-label extension; the extension is not a continuing randomized comparison.
Approach source: JAMA Neurology — original OPERA follow-up article ↗
- What kind of evidence exists?
- 1,628 OPERA I and II participants by self-reported race and ethnicity: 65 non-Hispanic Black, 213 Hispanic or Latino and 1,350 non-Hispanic White
- How reliable is this source?
- Peer-reviewed article in Multiple Sclerosis Journal; only the published abstract was reviewed. Post hoc subgroup analysis of two randomised Phase 3 trials, funded by Roche, with authors from Genentech and Roche.
- Research event/source date
- Published by MyelinWatch
- Last substantive MyelinWatch update